Cozy Potato Buttermilk Pie – Quick & Easy Recipe

Hi I'm Benjamin

Everyday Culinary Delights👩‍🍳

Posted on January 16, 2025

There’s something undeniably comforting about Sweet Potato Buttermilk Pie. It’s a dessert that brings warmth to the table, evoking memories of holiday feasts, family gatherings, and the scent of cinnamon and nutmeg filling the kitchen. This pie, rooted deeply in Southern culinary traditions, is the perfect balance of earthy sweetness, rich spices, and tangy buttermilk.

Whether you’re a seasoned baker or trying this recipe for the first time, this guide will walk you through why this pie is so special, expert baking tips, creative variations, serving suggestions, and common questions to help you perfect this classic treat.

Why Sweet Potato Buttermilk Pie is a Must-Try Dessert

1. A Perfect Harmony of Flavors

This pie is a delightful mix of natural sweetness from roasted sweet potatoes, warm spices like nutmeg and cinnamon, and a slight tang from buttermilk. The buttery, flaky crust adds texture, while the smooth, creamy filling melts in your mouth.

2. Rich in History and Tradition

Sweet potato pie has been a staple in Southern kitchens for generations. Unlike pumpkin pie, which became a Thanksgiving favorite in Northern states, sweet potato pie was embraced in the South due to the region’s abundance of sweet potatoes. Over time, variations developed, with buttermilk becoming a popular addition to enhance the pie’s creaminess.

3. Naturally Sweet and Nutrient-Rich

Unlike many other desserts, sweet potato pie provides nutritional benefits along with indulgence. Sweet potatoes are packed with:

Vitamin A and beta-carotene, which support eye health.
Fiber, aiding digestion and promoting fullness.
Natural sweetness, reducing the need for excessive sugar.

4. Buttermilk: The Secret Ingredient for Creaminess

Many traditional pies use heavy cream or condensed milk, but buttermilk creates a distinctively smooth and silky texture. The mild tanginess enhances the sweet potatoes, creating a perfectly balanced bite.

Ingredients:

Baked Sweet Potato Puree – 2 cups (about two medium sweet potatoes)
Unsalted Butter – 3 tablespoons, melted
Eggs – 2 large, beaten
All-Purpose Flour – 2 tablespoons
Ground Nutmeg – ½ teaspoon
Ground Cinnamon – ½ teaspoon
Salt – ½ teaspoon
Granulated Sugar – ½ cup
Buttermilk (Full-Fat) – ½ cup
Baking Soda – ½ teaspoon
Pie Crust – 1 (9-inch), homemade or store-bought
Whipped Cream – Optional, for serving

Directions:

Bake the Sweet Potatoes
- Preheat the oven to 400°F (200°C).
- Poke holes in the sweet potatoes, wrap them in foil, and bake for 50 minutes until tender.
- Let cool, peel, and mash until smooth.
Prebake the Pie Crust
- Reduce the oven temperature to 350°F (175°C).
- Prepare the pie crust in a 9-inch pie dish, following package or homemade crust instructions.
Prepare the Filling
- In a bowl, whisk together the sweet potato puree, melted butter, and beaten eggs.
- In another bowl, mix flour, nutmeg, cinnamon, salt, and sugar.
- Gradually combine the dry ingredients with the sweet potato mixture.
- Stir together buttermilk and baking soda, then blend into the filling.
Assemble and Bake
- Pour the mixture into the pie crust, smoothing the top.
- Bake for 65 minutes, until the center is set.
- Let cool completely before slicing.
Serve and Enjoy
- Top with whipped cream for extra indulgence.
- Serve at room temperature or chilled.

Nutritional Information (Per Serving):

Calories: 250
Protein: 4g
Total Fat: 12g
Carbohydrates: 30g
Fiber: 2g
Sugar: 15g
Sodium: Varies depending on ingredients used

Baking Tips for the Perfect Sweet Potato Buttermilk Pie

1. Roast, Don’t Boil, the Sweet Potatoes

Roasting sweet potatoes intensifies their natural sweetness while keeping the texture firm. Boiling, on the other hand, can introduce too much moisture, which might make the pie filling too watery.

2. Use Fresh, High-Quality Ingredients

Sweet Potatoes – Look for medium-sized sweet potatoes with smooth skin. Avoid large ones, as they can be too starchy.
Buttermilk – Use full-fat buttermilk for the creamiest texture.
Spices – Freshly ground nutmeg and cinnamon make a noticeable difference in flavor compared to pre-ground versions.

3. Avoid Overmixing the Batter

Overmixing can create air bubbles, leading to cracks in the pie. For the smoothest texture, mix the filling just until combined.

4. Prebake the Crust for a Crispier Base

For a pie crust that doesn’t turn soggy, blind bake it before adding the filling. Brush with an egg wash before prebaking to create a barrier between the crust and filling.

5. Check for Doneness Without Overbaking

The pie is done when the center is slightly firm but still has a slight jiggle. Overbaking can cause the filling to crack. Let the pie cool completely before slicing for the best texture.

Creative Variations of Sweet Potato Buttermilk Pie

1. Pecan-Topped Sweet Potato Pie

Add a crunchy contrast by sprinkling chopped pecans on top before baking or creating a candied pecan topping.

2. Maple-Sweetened Version

Swap the granulated sugar for pure maple syrup to introduce a deeper, caramel-like sweetness.

3. Bourbon-Spiked Sweet Potato Pie

A splash of bourbon in the filling enhances the pie’s richness and adds a subtle smoky note.

4. Ginger and Clove Infused Pie

For a spicier variation, add a pinch of ground ginger and cloves to the filling for a bolder, more aromatic profile.

5. Chocolate Swirl Sweet Potato Pie

Melt dark chocolate and swirl it into the filling before baking for a decadent chocolate twist.

Serving Suggestions for Sweet Potato Buttermilk Pie

1. Classic Whipped Cream Topping

A simple dollop of homemade whipped cream enhances the pie’s natural sweetness while adding a light, airy contrast to the dense filling.

2. Dusting of Powdered Sugar or Cinnamon

A light sprinkle of powdered sugar or cinnamon gives the pie an elegant finishing touch.

3. Vanilla or Cinnamon Ice Cream

Serve a warm slice with a scoop of vanilla or cinnamon ice cream for a delightful temperature contrast.

4. Drizzle of Caramel or Honey

A drizzle of warm caramel or honey can elevate the flavors even further.

5. Garnish with Candied Orange Peel

For a unique citrusy touch, garnish each slice with thin strips of candied orange peel.

Storage and Make-Ahead Tips

1. Storing in the Refrigerator

Once cooled, store the pie covered in plastic wrap or foil in the refrigerator for up to four days.

2. Freezing for Long-Term Storage

To freeze:

Wrap the pie tightly in plastic wrap and aluminum foil.
Freeze for up to three months.
Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before serving.

3. Making Ahead for Special Occasions

You can prepare the pie a day or two in advance, keeping it refrigerated until ready to serve. Allow it to come to room temperature before slicing.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I use canned sweet potato puree instead of fresh sweet potatoes?

Yes, but fresh roasted sweet potatoes offer better flavor and texture. If using canned, ensure it’s plain and unsweetened.

2. What’s the difference between sweet potato pie and pumpkin pie?

Sweet potato pie is generally sweeter, denser, and has a more robust flavor, while pumpkin pie has a lighter, more custard-like consistency.

3. Can I make this pie dairy-free?

Yes! Substitute buttermilk with almond or oat milk mixed with a teaspoon of lemon juice and use a plant-based butter alternative.

4. How do I prevent my pie from cracking?

Avoid overbaking – remove the pie when the center is still slightly jiggly.
Let it cool gradually – sudden temperature changes can cause cracks.

5. Can I make this pie crustless?

Yes! Pour the filling into a greased pie dish and bake as a sweet potato custard.

6. What’s the best way to reheat leftover pie?

Warm slices in a 350°F oven for 10 minutes or microwave for 20 seconds to bring back its fresh-from-the-oven taste.

Conclusion: A Slice of Southern Comfort

Sweet Potato Buttermilk Pie is more than just a dessert—it’s a celebration of tradition, flavor, and comfort. With its silky-smooth texture, warm spices, and flaky crust, it’s a timeless classic that belongs on every holiday table and family gathering.

Whether enjoyed as a simple weeknight treat or a show-stopping holiday dessert, this pie never fails to impress. With its rich history, endless variations, and simple preparation, it’s a recipe worth passing down for generations.

So why not bring a little Southern charm to your kitchen? Bake this pie, share it with loved ones, and savor every warm, spiced bite.